How to choose the best formation for your squad

# How to choose the best formation for your squad

One of the biggest decisions you make as a manager is your formation. But here’s the awkward truth: there is no perfect formation. What does exist is a formation that suits the players you’ve got. In ELDT you have 15 formations to choose from, and the temptation is to copy a shape you like without thinking about who you actually have available. That usually ends badly. Here’s how to think about it properly.

The trap we all fall into

You see a side playing an attacking 4-3-3 and think: "That’s what I need". But then it turns out that team has three rapid, hard-running wingers, and you’ve got box-to-box midfielders. You shove your best wide men out to full-back and pull the wingers out of systems where they were actually delivering. Result: your team loses shape and you start dropping points.

eldt.com.ar

It happens all the time. The formation doesn’t choose the players; the players choose the formation. That’s the first mindset shift.

What to check before you choose

Before you get stuck into the line-up, take stock:

1. How many good defenders do you have? Don’t just count bodies: look at overall, form and fitness. If you’ve got 5 or 6 defenders in decent shape, you can play a 5 or a solid back line. If you’ve got 3 or 4, 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 are safer.
2. Do you have fast wingers? Look at pace and whether they have the Quick speciality. The 4-3-3 lives on that. If your wide players are slow or more technical than quick, a 4-3-3 will hurt you. Playing down the flanks (a tactical style) with slower wide men is asking for trouble.
3. How many midfielders do you have in the middle? More midfielders means more control; fewer means more space. A 4-2-3-1 with a holding man gives you solidity. A 4-4-2 can leave the centre exposed if your rival lines up 4-3-3. A 4-1-4-1 is unusual, but if you’ve got a top-class defensive midfielder, you should use him.
4. What are your forwards like? Two strong but slow number nines: 4-4-2. One versatile, quick striker: 4-3-3 with a false 9. One lone striker: 4-5-1 or 5-3-2 depending on what you need. Two wingers and a 9: classic 4-3-3.
5. Which positions are weakest? If your defence is a mess but your midfield is brilliant, a 4-5-1 or 3-5-2 shuts the back door and lets you attack through the middle. It works the other way round too: if the defence is strong but the attack isn’t creating much, a safer 5-3-2 lets you counter and go long to find the 9.

The formations and what they’re for

The 4-4-2: the old classic

Four defenders, four midfielders, two forwards. Balanced, tried and tested. It works when you’ve got a well-rounded squad without any odd specialist roles. The defence is covered, the midfield has numbers, and you’ve got two up top. The problem: against a team with three midfielders, you can lose the centre.

When to use it: Well-balanced squads, rivals without a clear tactical structure, when you need stability.

The 4-3-3: attacking, high press

Three in midfield, three up front: two wingers and a 9. It’s for attacking, for pressing, for teams with pace. The 4-3-3 pushes up high and relies on quick switches out wide.

When to use it: You’ve got quick wingers, you want to press high, your defence is solid and your midfield can cover ground. If you don’t have quick wingers, it’s a suicide note.

The 5-3-2: ultra-defensive, built for counters

Five defenders (three centre-backs), three midfielders, two forwards. This is the shape of "we’re here to defend". The 5-3-2 is for teams that need security at the back and pace up top. The wing-backs go when you have the ball and get back when you don’t.

When to use it: You’re away to a stronger side, you need a draw, your defence is tidy but your attack is limited, or in cups when you want to hang on.

The 4-2-3-1: defensive shield with a playmaker

Four defenders, two holding midfielders, one playmaker, three up front. It gives you security at the back with the holding midfielder and a bit of magic in the final third. Modern shape, but it needs specific midfielders.

When to use it: You’ve got one strong holding midfielder and another creative midfielder, and you want balance with a bit more protection.

The 4-1-4-1: the lone holding midfielder

Just one defensive shield and everyone else looking to get forward. It’s aggressive and needs a top-class holding midfielder.

When to use it: Your defensive midfielder is outstanding and you want to go at teams with everything you’ve got.

The 3-5-2: three centre-backs, a crowded midfield

Three defenders, five midfielders (or four midfielders and a winger), two forwards. It crowds the middle and lets you play with width, with or without true wingers.

When to use it: Your midfield is your strength, you need defensive solidity but still want width.

The trick: build by form and fatigue

Once you’ve chosen your formation, in the ELDT line-up screen there’s a button called Build by form and fatigue. It does two things:

• Sends tired players to the bench, even if they’re starters.
• Keeps the formation and puts the best players in each position.

I use this more often than "Build the best" because a player with overall 18 but form 35 will contribute less than one with overall 15 and form 80. Form is what matters week by week.

One more thing: mentality

The formation is the shape; mentality is the attitude. The same 4-4-2, but very defensive versus very attacking, plays completely differently. You choose mentality in the line-up screen too, and it runs from very defensive to very attacking.

A very defensive 5-3-2 versus a very attacking 4-3-3 is the difference between hanging on in a cup tie and getting swamped.

eldt.com.ar

The golden advice

Don’t design the formation first. Look at your players, work out who your best men are in each area, and then build the system that suits them. If you’ve got a top-class centre-back but only two average full-backs, a 5-3-2 helps. If you’ve got two fiery wingers and a small 9, 4-3-3 all day long.

The best managers don’t invent systems: they adapt what they have to what their players can do. And that only comes from looking at overall, form, fitness and specialities.

Set up your club →